© 2024 Connecticut Public

FCC Public Inspection Files:
WPKT · WRLI-FM · WEDW-FM · Public Files Contact
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

How to bake a 700-pound whoopie pie

Two people pour cake batter into a massive circular pan
Megan Wagner
The Dream Maker Bakers team prepares the first attempt at Rutland's massive whoopie pie in 2022.

Rutland is hosting its second annual Whoopie Pie Festival on Saturday from noon to five. Organizers say there will be food trucks and family-friendly activities — but the star attraction is an enormous whoopie pie.

If you've never had a whoopie pie, imagine two layers of velvety cake with a silky marshmallow filling. That’s how Megan Wagner, the owner of Dream Maker Bakers, described it.

Now imagine one that’s 700 pounds.

“It's really hard to describe how technical this really is, and how many things that we have to think about — because it really, really is an impressive feat keeping that cake in one solid piece," Wagner said.

Last year, for Rutland’s inaugural festival, she made a 542-pound whoopie pie. This year’s had to be bigger.

“So for the overall project, we use almost 100 pounds of flour, two 50-pound bags," Wagner said. "For butter, we're going to bring in 72 pounds."

She'll use 180 eggs and 72 pounds of marshmallow fluff.

“I think the most astonishing number is probably the powdered sugar that goes into the filling. There's 180 pounds of powdered sugar in the filling alone," Wagner said, laughing.

Six people stand behind a table with a giant whoopie pie with a Dreammaker Bakers purple label on top
The Chamber and Economic Development of the Rutland Region
Last year's 542-pound whoopie pie at the Whoopie Pie Festival in Rutland. This year's attempt will be even bigger, says Megan Wagner, the owner of Dreammaker Bakers (third from left).

To actually bake the oversized cakes she had to have a special pan made that's four-and-a-half feet in diameter. A Killington pizzeria lets her use their five-foot-wide pizza oven.

“It's not quite big enough, as far as the depth, but we got really creative, my husband and I," Wagner said. "He made a custom-made stainless steel extender box that allows us to leave the door open, and then it encloses and keeps all of the heat in the oven.”

To make sure the cake cooks evenly, they have to rotate it several times during its two hours of baking. Then comes one of the most challenging parts of the entire process.

“Taking it out of the oven is much more scary then putting it in," Wagner said, "because at that point, you know, the whole thing is 350 degrees and 200 pounds.”

She says having to tilt the cakes to get them through doorways is also unnerving.

This year, Black River Produce is lending Wagner a refrigerated box truck, which should make transporting the dessert to Rutland easier.

Megan Wagner, the owner of Dreammaker Bakers in Killington, has to bake the oversized whoopie pie cakes in a custom 4.5-foot-diameter pan.
The Chamber and Economic Development of the Rutland Region
Megan Wagner, the owner of Dreammaker Bakers in Killington, has to bake the oversized whoopie pie cakes in a custom 4.5-foot-diameter pan.

Once they get there, the oversized delectable will be on display before an official weigh-in at 4 p.m. Then it'll be sliced up for the crowd to enjoy. Wagner says that’s when she’ll finally be able to say whoopie.

“Like right now, you know, I'm telling myself, 'Why did I say yes to this again?' Wagner said. "But once we get on the other side and it's Sunday morning, that feeling of joy and excitement and accomplishment just completely overrules any stress I went through to get there, and I kind of forget about it all.”

A South Portland Maine bakery created a whoopie pie that weighed over a thousand pounds in 2011. Wagner believes she can top that and hopes to try. But first, she just wants to get this one done.

Any leftovers will be boxed and frozen and delivered to food shelves all over the state.

Have questions, comments or tips?Send us a message or reach out to reporter Nina Keck:


One in five Vermonters is considered elderly. But what does being elderly even mean — and what do Vermonters need to know as they age? I’m looking into how aging in Vermont impacts living essentials such as jobs, health care and housing. And also how aging impacts the stuff of life: marriage, loss, dating and sex.

Stand up for civility

This news story is funded in large part by Connecticut Public’s Members — listeners, viewers, and readers like you who value fact-based journalism and trustworthy information.

We hope their support inspires you to donate so that we can continue telling stories that inform, educate, and inspire you and your neighbors. As a community-supported public media service, Connecticut Public has relied on donor support for more than 50 years.

Your donation today will allow us to continue this work on your behalf. Give today at any amount and join the 50,000 members who are building a better—and more civil—Connecticut to live, work, and play.

Related Content